Eastbourne councillors have updated their constitution to reflect controversial changes to national planning rules.
Article written by: Huw Oxburgh - Local Democracy Reporter
On Wednesday (November 18), members of Eastbourne Borough Council agreed to update the authority’s constitution to reflect changes required as a result of the recently-introduced National Scheme of Delegation.
In broad terms, the scheme sets out new national rules about what types of planning applications can be decided by committees and what types of proposals must be decided by officers alone.
Before holding the vote councillors first heard from several public speakers and planning committee chairman Hugh Parker.
Cllr Parker (Lib Dem) said: “There is no doubt that the new legislation … creates, in the minds of some and certainly in mine, a democratic deficit.
“However, we have to comply with the law and in order to comply with the law we have to adjust and amend the constitution accordingly.”
He added: “The national scheme of delegation, if not applied, could expose the council to financial, legal and reputational risks and officers explained that very carefully at the planning meeting.
“We have to … vote with great reluctance [to] approve the principle here. However, there is no doubt that to not vote for it would create a considerable number of problems for this council and possibly take away our planning capability. So I recommend that the proposal is accepted.”
Among other changes, the new rules remove the ability of ward councillors to “call-in” applications to be heard at a planning committee meeting.
This was a particular concern for Conservative councillor Nick Ansell, a member of the planning committee who had put forward an amendment to the proposals.
Cllr Ansell said: “For years the ultimate safety net of our planning system has been a simple democratic truth; that the people who live in a community and the local ward councillors they elect have a right to hold developers and officers to account in the light of day.
“Yet the central, most dangerous mechanism of these new planning rules is the complete elimination of the councillors’ power to call-in applications, coupled with a mandatory decree that any development under 10 homes must be decided by unelected officers alone.”
He added: “Our planning officers are dedicated, hardworking professionals, but they are bound by macro level guidelines, rigid criteria and the National Planning Policy Framework; they are forced to treat applications as a tick-box exercise.
“In committee our job is different; our job is to look past the spreadsheets and examine the human impact of a development.”
Cllr Ansell’s amendment did not alter the required constitutional changes, but called on the leader of the council to write to the secretary of state.
The amendment requests that this letter would both set out the council’s objections to the scheme and call for it to be either repealed or amended to restore the ability of ward members to call-in applications.
Cllr Peter Diplock, the council’s cabinet member for planning, confirmed the Liberal Democrat group would support the amendment.
He said: “One of the things I have always loved about planning committee is it is non-partisan. Genuinely, people get there to try and make the right decision for the area and for the time.
“The government’s involvement here is stymying that and is making it unworkable and is unfair. For that reason, we will write to the government in the strongest possible way.”
Cllr Diplock said the council would also be supporting calls from the Local Government Association (LGA), which also seek the restoration of call-in powers.
The LGA is also calling on the government to bring forward its planned statutory review of the scheme, which is currently due to take place in 2028.
The constitutional changes were agreed on a majority vote.

Eastbourne man awaits sentencing after admitting grevious bodily harm stabbing a boy
Motor Mechanic Students Given Facilities to Learn Eco Car Skills in Hastings
Brighton artist recreates Marilyn Monroe's iconic dress to raise money for cancer charity
Morning swimming set to return in New Year at Seaford Head Pool